Mindfulness Group Discussion on Dharma Hall Space, April 30, 2005

Present:  Karen Fitzgerald, Ted Williams, Danna Zelenka, Brenda Miller, Jenn Hebert, Eileen Kiera, Kate Haskell, Sofia Haskell (age 6)

 

We received an overview of the Hall’s financial structure, from Jenn, then we proceeded to answer the questions set out in the Hall’s survey of groups:

 

  1. How does the Mindfulness Group benefit from the being part of the Dharma Hall?

 

--the hall provides a consistent place of practice that is easy to get to, set up and maintain.

--it’s easy on us financially as a group (we’re not responsible, as a group, for rent and maintenance costs).

--it helps us support others who are not yet committed to practice

--we like being part of a larger Buddhist community; it provides  mutual energy and support for practice (having the energy of others sitting in the same space)

--it makes us more visible to newcomers

--efficient use of common resources, such as zafus, etc.

--we have enough space for both regular practice and larger events.

 

The Mindfulness group does not anticipate a specific growth in size (our numbers continually fluctuate), but perhaps a small growth in the kinds of offerings, such as a non-residential retreat at the hall.  We average 10 people per sitting night.

 

 

  1. What are the drawbacks of being part of the dharma hall?

 

--since we don’t have to take as much responsibility for the hall, it can be “too easy”; we don’t have to mature and “grow up” as a sangha and take full responsibility for ourselves.

--newcomers may not get as committed to our group, since they may keep “shopping around.”  This kind of “shopping mall” mentality can perhaps dilute the energy.

--since we are a small group, a few people end up taking on more jobs, both within sangha and the larger dharma hall.  This can lead to burnout.

--we are committed to developing Mountain Lamp, a rural retreat center for our group; being part of the dharma hall can perhaps draw resources (financial and human) away from Mountain Lamp and our own sangha’s needs.

--the physical space we have now does not provide any area for extended walking meditation, which is an important part of our practice.

--the space we have now is very noisy, with street noise, the Aikido group, and the noise and inconsistency of the heaters.  Does not  provide a conducive atmosphere for quiet reflection, dharma discussion, and dharma talks.

--there is no adequate space to have a kids/family program going on at the same time as regular sitting.  This is important for our practice.

--there is no separate foyer for less disturbance from latecomers.

--there is no separate meeting space, to keep the sanctity of the zendo intact.

--there is no accessibility for the disabled.

 

  1. What are we doing as a group to support the Dharma Hall?

 

--100% of the group present are members of the dharma hall and pay dues; a large percentage of our group members are also members of the dharma hall.

--We give 10% of earning from events, but we’ve given less in the recent past, since all our events have been strictly teacher dana.

--We provide a place for Mindfulness practice.

--We provide a representative to the Board and to the Space Committee.

--We provide a member to maintain the website.

--we clean the hall as part of our working meditation.

--we participate in larger hall events.

 

4.      What is the group’s involvement with the larger sangha? Would you like to see more “meta sangha” events?

 

--Yes, we enjoy events with members of other sanghas, and we’d like to see activities increase, such as a Kids’ program, and another “open sitting” such as a 5:00 sitting.

--we discussed how the dharma hall and its groups are really creating and discovering what Buddhism looks like in the west, and how traditional Buddhist monastic practices can translate into lay practices.

 

 

  1. Outreach?

 

--We feel uncomfortable with outreach efforts that might take on the aspect of “recruitment,” such as having a booth at a non-Buddhist event.   Presence at Buddhist oriented events seems appropriate.

--It is important for the dharma hall to develop a “shared values and vision statement”  that will guide all our efforts.

--We are interested in perhaps having “service outreach” programs, where members of the dharma hall participate together in a community service project.

 

  1. What kind of responsibility/commitment can we make as a group if we were to move to a more expensive space?

 

--Since we are a small group, with a core group of about 8 people, we would not be able at this time to commit to a lease or mortgage payment.

--Since we are committed to supporting Mountain Lamp, and our teacher Eileen Kiera, many of our financial resources go there as well.

--We can bolster our efforts to encourage individuals to become part of the dharma hall.

--We do not at this time require financial membership in our sangha, but we are open to discussing that as part of our evolution. We discussed whether or not more people would be more inclined to financially commit to and support individual groups they attend, rather than the bigger concept of the dharma hall.  We will have a sangha discussion about this topic.  If we decide to have financial memberships in our group, a portion of this money would go to the dharma hall.

--We do commit to staying with the dharma hall for many years to come.

 

 

7.      Would you be willing to share space with other tenants, or pool resources with outside groups also looking for a space?

 

--We would strongly prefer the dharma hall house only the four meditation groups.  We would be open to other Buddhist practitioners using the space for Buddhist events.

--If it’s absolutely necessary to share the space, it would have to be a group that does nothing to impact the practice or dilute the group’s energy in managing the relationship with the tenants.

--We might be open to renting any space that’s not directly used for meditation, but it would have to be in line with our values and practice.  For instance, renting a bedroom to a dharma practitioner.

 

 

8.      What is most important to your group for the new space?

 

--an adequate space for outdoor walking meditation; this can either be on the grounds itself, or the hall could be backed up/within walking distance to a green space or a large park.

--a separate space for Kids/Family program

--Quiet

--Accessibility